United Nations
Department of Economic and Social Affairs
Hosted by the Government Blockchain Association
The solutions below have been assessed and rated by Authorized BMM Professionals
in accordance with the Blockchain Maturity Model
and referenced by the GBA and the UN IGF Blockchain Assurance & Standardization Dynamic Coalition.
Directory of GBA BMM Rated Trusted Blockchain Solutions
Closed
Banking & Financial Services - Tapestry (Level 1) - L4S Corp
| Assessment ID | 2023-GBA-2 |
| Name of the solution assessed | L4S “TapestryX |
| Announcement | TapestryX Rated as a Trusted Blockchain Solution |
| Meta data of the solution | |
| Description |
TapestryX is designed to support real-time, scalable, and high-capacity distributed ledger networks for institutional and retail financial services, industry, governments, service providers and data managers, based on the following capabilities: ● Real-time, scalable, high-capacity, and self-synchronizing (no need for consensus) ● Double-entry accounting and GAAP configurable with real-time trial balance monitoring ● Event-driven updates with flexible, simple, and customizable scripting ● Interoperable with legacy and infrastructure. |
| Current phase | Production Ready |
| Solution Layer (Layer 1, Layer 2, Other) | Layer 1 |
| Domain (Financial, Healthcare, Identity, Supply Chain, Voting, Other) | Financial, Other |
| Blockchain Type (Private, Public, Hybrid) | Private |
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Name and contact information of the assessment sponsor |
Paul Dowding Head of Design, L4S Corporation pfdowding@l4scorp.com |
| Name & contact information of the Assessment Team Leader |
Government Blockchain Association BMM@GBAglobal.org |
| End date the assessment | 30 May 2023 |
| Assessment Results: | |
| Element ratings | All Elements rated at Level 1 |
| Solution maturity rating | Level 1 |
| Supplemental rating(s) | Banking & Financial Services |
Gaming - AXES Integrity (Level 1) - AXES.ai
| Assessment Points of Contact | |
| Organization | AXES.ai |
| Website | www.AXES.ai |
| Solution POC | Nicolas Tremblay |
| POC Contact | nt@AXES.ai |
| Lead Assessor | Frederic de Vaulx |
| Solution Information | |
| Blockchain Solution | Axes Integrity |
| Description / Scope | The solution enables AXES AIMS platform users to verify the integrity of the data in the report they generate on the platform. This will be achieved through a smart contract in a secure environment that guarantees data integrity and data privacy. |
| Version/Configuration ID | 1.0 |
| Current Phase | Planning |
| Solution Layer (Layer 1 or Layer 1&2 or Other) | Layer 1 Application |
| Infrastructure | Cloud + Blockchain |
| Network Protocol | Ethereum |
| # of Nodes | + 2,000 |
| Supplement (Financial, Healthcare, Identity, Supply Chain, Voting, Other) | N/A |
| Blockchain Type (Private, Public, Hybrid) | Public |
| Industry | Gaming |
| Function |
|
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Name and contact information of the BMM Assessment Partner | Government Blockchain Association |
| Assessment ID Number | 2023-GBA-1 |
| Start & end date the assessment | March 23 – April 31, 2023 |
| Assessment Results: | |
| Element ratings | All Elements Rated at Level One. |
| Solution maturity rating | Level One |
Layer 1 - Oracle Blockchain Platform
| Name of the Blockchain Solution Assessed | Oracle Blockchain Platform |
| Meta Data of the Solution | |
| Description / Scope |
The assessment covers the solution of Oracle Blockchain Platform as a managed blockchain service of Hyperledger Fabric in Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) and on-premises/3rd party cloud Enterprise Edition. The platform supports permissioned, private and consortium implementations. It is not an assessment of either Oracle’s platforms or Hyperledger Fabric individually. |
| Version/Configuration ID | Oracle v23.3.3 (Hyperledger Fabric 2.5.3). |
| Current Phase | Production |
| Solution Layer (Layer 1 or Layer 1&2 or Other) | Layer 1 |
| Infrastructure | Oracle Cloud Infrastructure & Oracle Blockchain Platform |
| Network Protocol | Hyperledger Fabric |
| # of Nodes | Dependent on requirements of the ecosystem where it’s deployed |
| Supplement (Financial, Healthcare, Identity, Supply Chain, Voting, Other) | Varied |
| Blockchain Type (Private, Public, Hybrid) | Private |
| Industry | Varied |
| Function | Blockchain solution implementation, control and management |
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Name and contact information of the BMM Assessment Partner | Government Blockchain Association |
| Assessment ID Number | 005 |
| Start & end date the assessment | 4/15/2024 – 4/23/2024 |
| Assessment Results: | |
| Element ratings | All elements are Level 1 |
| Solution maturity rating | Level 1 |
Identity Management - EarthID (Level 1) - EarthID Technology Ltd
| Name of the Solution Assessed | EarthID |
| Solution Description | |
| Description | EarthID is a multi-award-winning decentralized identity platform that enables organizations to safeguard, minimize and reuse personally identifiable customer data. EarthID helps organizations prevent identity frauds, drive compliance, increase operational efficiency and foster customer trust, while empowering users with data ownership, privacy, and consent. EarthID’s mission is to build a user-centric identity which is resistant to threats from generative AI and quantum computing. EarthID’s longer term vision is to drive social, financial, and digital inclusion |
| Current Phase | Live |
| Network Layer | Hedera |
| Domain | Digital Identity Management |
| Blockchain Type | Public |
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Assessment Sponsor | Shiv Aggarwal, CTO, EarthID |
| Assessment Organization | Government Blockchain Association |
| Assessment End Date | January 20, 2024 |
| Publication Date: | February 12, 2024 |
| Assessment Results | |
| Element Ratings | All Elements Rated at Level One |
| Solution Maturity Rating | Level One |
Voting - Voatz Remote Accessible Ballot Delivery, Marking & Return (Level 1) - Voatz, Inc.
| Assessment ID | 2023-GBA-3 |
| Name of the solution assessed | Voatz RABDMR (Remote Accessible Ballot Delivery, Marking & Return) system |
| Meta data of the solution | |
| Description | Voatz is an award-winning mobile elections platform that is changing the way the world votes. Backed by cutting-edge security, biometrics and a blockchain-backed infrastructure, Voatz enables smartphone voting to increase accessibility and security in elections. Since 2016, Voatz has successfully served more than 2.3 million voters across 125 elections with several governments, major political parties, unions and associations. In 2018, Voatz ran the first mobile vote in US Federal Election history, and, in 2020, Voatz became the first smartphone app-based system to be used for voting in the US Presidential Elections. Voatz was recently selected by 15 cities in Canada for the 2022 Ontario Municipal Elections and is now expanding in several other markets. |
| Current phase | Production |
| Solution Layer (Layer 1, Layer 2, Other) | Layer 1&2 |
| Domain (Financial, Healthcare, Identity, Supply Chain, Voting, Other) | Voting |
| Blockchain Type (Private, Public, Hybrid) | Hybrid Permissioned |
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Name and contact information of the assessment sponsor |
Orlando Alomá |
| Name & contact information of the Assessment Team Leader |
Government Blockchain Association BMM@GBAglobal.org |
| End date the assessment | 6 September 2023 |
| Assessment Results: | |
| Element ratings | All elements rated at Level 1 |
| Solution maturity rating | Level 1 |
| Supplemental rating(s) | N/A |
Voting - (Level 1) - DeVOTE DAO LLC
| Organization | DeVOTE DAO LLC |
| Website | devoteusa.com |
| Solution POC | Eugene Morozov |
| POC Contact | me@devoteusa.com |
| Lead Assessor | Frederic de Vaulx |
| Solution Information | |
| Blockchain Solution | DeVOTE |
| Description / Scope |
DeVOTE is a Zero Knowledge Proof-based scalable, open source, decentralized remote ballot marking and return mobile voting system on blockchain allowing safe, secure, compliant, accessible, affordable and most importantly indisputable elections.
It ensures that a vote has been (1) cast as intended, (2) recorded as cast, (3) tallied as recorded (4) reported as tallied. |
| Version/Configuration ID | 1.0 |
| Current Phase |
Prototype / In Development MVP
|
| Solution Layer (Layer 1 or Layer 1&2 or Other) | Layer 2 Application |
| Infrastructure | User Device, Blockchain |
| Network Protocol | Multi-chain Capability |
| # of Nodes |
DeVOTE follows the principles of sufficient decentralisation described in Everscale whitepaper by Mitja Goroshevsky https://www.cryptocompare.com/media/39109012/everscale.pdf Currently Everscale network employs 177 validators up to 420. Validators can be found at https://everscan.io/validators As gosh is using the same validator network, the numbers are similar to that of Everscale. |
| Supplement (Financial, Healthcare, Identity, Supply Chain, Voting, Other) | N/A |
| Blockchain Type (Private, Public, Hybrid) | Public, Private, Hybrid |
| Industry | Elections |
| Function | Safe, secure, accessible, affordable, indisputable elections |
| Assessment Metadata | |
| Name and contact information of the BMM Assessment Partner | Government Blockchain Association |
| Assessment ID Number | 2024-GBA-2 |
| Start & end date the assessment | Apr 25- Apr 26, 2024 |
| Assessment Results: | |
| Element ratings | All Elements Rated at Level 1 |
| Solution maturity rating | Level 1 |